Pizza Shackamaxon took over the original Pizzeria Beddia location, when it was just a counter shop, without anyone noticing. While there aren’t lines out the door anymore, these thin-crust pies are really f*cking good. Shackamaxon sells their pizza by the slice, so you don’t have to purchase an entire pizza for yourself to eat on your couch (unless you want to). And despite how huge the slices are, they hold their weight in toppings - meaning your pepperoni-covered pizza won’t lose all of its perfect little grease pools as soon as you pick up a slice. It’s a neighborhood pizza spot that you should travel for, and despite how incredible it is, you’ll be in and out in 10 minutes flat.
Where we've featured it
More spots in FishtownSee more
Philly Style Bagels
Philly Style Bagels in Fishtown is our favorite bagel shop in the city, bar none.
Ekta Indian Cuisine
Ekta is an Indian BYOB in Fishtown that works well for big groups and carry out.
Murph’s is an Irish pub in Fishtown that also happens to make some of our favorite Italian food in the city.
More Pizza spotsSee more
Spuntino is a neighborhood pizza place in Northern Liberties that makes some of the best Neapolitan pies in the area.
Talula’s is a pizza place in Asbury Park with some of the best baked goods and Neopolitan pies down the shore.
Sarcone’s in the Italian Market is where all the good cheesesteak places get their rolls, but they also have good pizza and desserts.
Suggested by our writers
Pizzeria Beddia is a sit-down pizza spot in Fishtown with arguably the best pizza in the city, plus a natural wine list and excellent soft serve.
Circles + Squares
Even though you might wait a while at Circles + Squares in Olde Richmond, it’s worth it to get the best pizza in Philly.
Wm. Mulherin’s Sons
Wm. Mulherin’s Sons is an Italian restaurant in Fishtown where you should go for a date or a nicer-than-usual weeknight dinner.
Filter and browse restaurants near you
Text us for personalized recommendationsLearn more